Heren Istarion Home
About Heren Istarion
Become a Member of Heren Istarion!
Newsletter
Heren Istarion Events
Heren Istarion Store
The Green Dragon Inn Forum
Parma Nole
Beyond the Shire
New York Hobbit
Recommended Links
Heren Istarion Contests
Games Workshop


Commentary on Ancanar Trailer
by Anthony S Burdge
Chairman The New York Tolkien Society

To pay homage to J.R.R. Tolkien and at the same time tackle themes he held dear in a film project is a huge undertaking. The earlier tales of Middle-earth record the deeds of heroes in the form of ancient narrative. They are not mere fantasy but the stuff of legend.

Enter Ancanar.

A film by devoted Tolkien fans, Writer/Director Sam Balcomb andWriter/Producer/Actress Raiya Corsiglia. Though unable to secure the rights to The Silmarillion and The Unfinished Tales (and The Lord of the Rings tied up in other film projects), Balcomb and Corsiglia present to us a unique story with Tolkien fans in mind.

Unlike previous fantasy films, Ancanar is rich in characters that have their own depth of history, ancient griefs, motivations and mythical archetypes. Balcomb and Corsiglia fashion a world similar to Middle-earth's First Age but original in its story.

In a Scene 360 Interview Balcomb states: "I usually always like to focus on character driven stories" The Ancanar trailer honors this vision tremendously. The opening sequence speaks of a hidden elven kingdom. If you are familiar with The Unfinished Tales then this hints of the city of Gondolin where elves dwell in secret. "None may espy under the penalty of death" harks the narrator. With this we are shown a possible trespasser being dispatched by Elven Captain Finlome played by British actor Ralph Lister.

We know that elves are not always dazzling light and soft voices, here their more violent streak is perfectly captured. Dark days were plentiful for Tolkien's elves, respecting that why should Balcomb and Corsiglia's creations be any different? What I also admire is that these elves have no pointy ears. Read Balcomb's article on Elven anatomy and see why.

"The Search Begins" after we are told of elves dwelling in a hidden kingdom and a dying father. This makes perfect sense, seek the life-sustaining secret of the elves to aid your dying father, very unique twist to understanding death and immortality. Bravo Sam and Raiya!

The tone, mood, and air of the trailer seems heavy and sad at moments, perhaps to assist the portrayal of immortality. The weight of being forever bound to the earth must be grave and meloncholical at times for the elves and its is captured perfectly by Balcomb, Corsiglia and the actors. When Ancanar questions Finlome on "mortal man dying of sickness and age while they are granted life eternal," (if you are reading this Gregory Kenyon, marvelous performance!) I practically wept. The weight of the elves is in captured brilliantly performed by Lister and shows Balcomb has no fear in tackling the issues of death and immortality. This new twist to seeking answers shows the movie goes head on to confront the issues.

These are not the issues your run of the mill fantasy film tackles. Though I am sure Ancanar will have its share of visual effects (as we see in the Ancanar Specials concerning the Rammoth Valley and commentary) this is an emotionally fed character story.

One particular character who is seemingly a mystery is Laliel portrayed by writer/producer/actress Raiya Corsiglia.

Throughout the trailer she seems to be on the run, avoiding to be seen. What we know of her is that she was captured while escaping the destruction of her village. There is not much to be said of Laliel in the material we have on the film but I shall make a stab in the dark here as to her character's role and nature:
1) She may possibly be an elf and one half an elf kind and mortal man romance dynamic or
2) She has the answers that Ancanar seeks.

But we will only know upon viewing the film

Recently Jessica and I was quoted on Ancanar.com as saying:
"…Ancanar, in our opinion, is the only film project that weaves the heart of Tolkien's themes into its mythical tapestry."
Balcomb and Corsiglia present issues and themes only characters could drive forth. Throughout the trailer, production journey and related material we can already see that all involved in this project do not stray from the course they have set for themselves. The actors all apparently give very strong performances and gear to give us all a tremendous show.

What give Ancanar its "Epic" nature, quality and feel is Balcomb and Corsiglia's command of Tolkien's work and his influences. "The spirit of 'northernness'" as Tolkien would say, the heroic, mythical aspects only found in the ancient sagas and eddas is found in Ancanar.

I would like to thank the Ancanar team for honoring Tolkien in their work and for upholding the spirit of Middle-earth with truth and honesty.